Home
>Health>
Youth Sports Medicine
"He Rubs the Same Spot on His Shoulder Without Even Noticing He's Doing It. Says He's Fine Before You Even Ask. We Explained Away Every Sign for a Month."
The small habits a baseball dad excused as nothing, until normal turned into an exam room.
I want to start with the part most dads don't say out loud. I was proud of our routine. I'd built it carefully. And my son still ended up with a diagnosis anyway.
Jake is 12. Third base mostly, pitches when the rotation needs him. Last September, an orthopedist pressed around his shoulder for about a minute and gave it a name.
"Bursitis, overuse pattern. No throwing for three weeks, reassess after."
We had a fall tournament in ten days.
I didn't argue. When a doctor says stop, you stop, and I wasn't about to negotiate a kid's shoulder against a weekend tournament. What I never accepted was that "rest and hope" was supposed to be the entire lesson here.
Everything We Already Had In Place
I want to list this out specifically, because I think the specifics are the point.
A pitch count app, checked religiously after every outing.
J-Bands, $38, used before every single throwing session without fail.
An ice wrap, $32, that we fought about more nights than we used successfully.
Biofreeze, then Icy Hot when the Biofreeze stopped doing much of anything.
A foam roller. A cheap massage ball. KT Tape applied from a tutorial I watched twice.
A magnesium spray a teammate's mom recommended, that dried before he'd finished rubbing it into his shoulder.
A little over $270 across one season, and he still ended up on that exam table.
The Signs I Brushed Off
It wasn't one moment. It was a string of small things I'd been quietly excusing for weeks.
The way he'd reach across his chest and rub the same spot without seeming to notice he was doing it.
"I'm fine" said in the exact same flat tone every single time, whether I'd asked or not.
A hesitation before a hard throw across the infield that I now realize I'd been watching happen for almost a month.
I told myself he barely pitched that stretch, so it couldn't be a throwing issue. I told myself the bands meant we were covered. I told myself it was ordinary baseball soreness, the kind every kid on the team probably dealt with.
Normal turned into an exam room.
What I Didn't Understand About Arm Recovery
A couple weeks into the shutdown, our trainer sat down with me and answered the question that had been bothering me since the appointment.
"We followed the pitch count. How did this happen?"
"Pitching isn't the whole throwing day," he said. "The shoulder doesn't just send the ball forward, it has to brake the arm after every single release. Long toss, infield throws, warmups, all of it has a stop your shoulder has to control. The scorebook counts pitches. His shoulder counts everything."
I asked him about the rubs we'd been using. He explained that Biofreeze and Icy Hot are counter-irritants:
check_circle
They activate cold or warm receptors on the skin's surface
check_circle
The brain temporarily quiets the soreness signal underneath while it processes the new sensation
check_circle
"Temporarily" is the operative word, the muscle itself never gets touched
check_circle
That's why the same tube stops feeling like it's working after a while, the brain just adjusts to the trick
"Every contraction has two sides," he told me. "Calcium fires the muscle. Magnesium supports the side that lets it relax back down. A counter-irritant works on skin receptors. Magnesium chloride works on the muscle relaxation side. Different system."
Then: "Long-term arm care isn't only what happens before he throws. It's also what happens after."
Grading What Was Already In the Bag
I went back through everything with that in mind.
Pitch counts: important, but only ever counted the mound, never the warmups or infield work.
J-Bands: genuinely useful, built entirely to prepare the arm before throwing, never to help it recover after.
Ice: fine on paper, but if he fights it most nights, it's not actually a routine.
Biofreeze and Icy Hot: a real sensation, zero effect on the tightness underneath it.
The magnesium spray: the right mineral, the wrong delivery, gone before it had any real contact time on the skin.
Every item fell into one of two piles. Before throwing. Or for when something already hurt badly enough to grab for it.
Nothing in our bag was built for the ordinary after, the regular Tuesday practice, the evening after a long infield session, when nothing was technically wrong but his shoulder still needed something.
What I Was Told To Look For
Our trainer didn't recommend a brand outright. He told me what to look for: magnesium chloride as the active ingredient, a cream rather than a spray for real contact time, and nothing with a harsh menthol additive that would just be another counter-irritant in a different tube.
Another baseball dad in our group mentioned the one his family kept in the bag. LeStrova Magnesium Relief Cream. Dead Sea magnesium chloride. Cream, not spray. Built specifically for sore, tight, overworked throwing-arm muscles after baseball, not before it.
What This Cream Is Not
I want to be straightforward about this before anything else.
This is not a treatment for bursitis or any structural shoulder issue, and it would not have changed Jake's diagnosis if we'd had it sooner. That's not its job. If your kid has sharp pain, pain that's getting worse, popping, swelling, or anything beyond ordinary soreness, that's a doctor's visit, not a jar of cream.
What it's for is the category our routine never had: the regular after-throwing evenings that quietly add up when nothing's waiting for the arm at the end of them.
What Changed, Day By Day
Day 1: After practice, post-shower, he rubbed it in expecting the usual sting out of habit. Nothing. He mentioned it didn't smell "like medicine."
Day 5: A heavy infield day. He asked where I'd put the jar before I'd said anything.
Day 11: A tournament weekend, back-to-back games. The after-step happened regardless. Shower, cream, dinner, bed.
Week 2: I stopped having to remind him.
Month 1: The jar sat next to his cleats, not buried in a cabinet I had to remember to check.
Month 2: Pitch counts during the game. Bands before throwing. Rest on the days something feels real. A doctor if it ever happens again. LeStrova after every throwing day, not just the hard ones.
That's the system now. Not a recovery plan for one diagnosis. A routine for every ordinary day going forward.
Do Not Just Take Our Word For It
I Can't Make You Try This
You've already heard to track the pitch count. You probably already have bands, ice, a rub in the bag. You've heard every opinion there is about mechanics, rest, and coaches who care more about Sunday's lineup than Monday's shoulder.
You don't need another dad online telling you this replaces any of that. It doesn't.
But here's what I wish someone had told me before that exam room: the problem was never that we hadn't found the right rub. The problem was that our whole routine was built around before throwing and around emergencies, and his shoulder still had to wind down after every ordinary practice in between, and nothing we owned was built for that.
Two categories. Long-term arm care, or waiting for the next appointment. I picked a third one.
You already built the warmup. Build the wind-down too.
With hope,
Dave Holloway
P.S. Jake finished the rest of fall ball without a single night of that chest-rubbing habit I'd been quietly watching for weeks. I noticed before I realized I'd been counting.
