Home
>Health>
Youth Sports Medicine
Top Private Pitching Coach: This Is the After-Throwing Step That Completes the Arm-Care Routine Most Baseball Families Have Already Spent $3,000+ Building Around
A private pitching coach with eleven years and 400+ youth athletes explains why the lesson itself is the throwing session no arm-care routine has ever been built to catch — and the one step that finally makes the whole routine complete
I want to start with something I have watched happen to enough families in my program that I now say it in the very first conversation.
You have already spent the money. The lessons. The tournament fees. The gear. The private instruction. The travel ball registration. The bat, the glove, the helmet, the bags. For most families in my roster, that adds up to somewhere between three thousand and five thousand dollars in a single season of serious youth baseball.
And almost none of them built anything for what happens after the throwing stops.
I have been giving private pitching lessons for eleven years. I have worked with over four hundred youth throwing athletes. I have watched enough shutdowns happen to kids I was actively coaching — kids whose families did everything right by every standard measure — to understand something that took me a long time to say out loud.
The routines these families built were real. The effort was real. The money was real. And the routine had the same gap every single time.
If you came here because you read a baseball mom's account of her son's Little League Shoulder shutdown and you recognized your own routine in it, I want to give you the version of that conversation from inside the lesson. From the person who has been on the other side of that invisible throwing volume for over a decade.
What Every Family's Arm-Care Routine Looks Like When I Ask About It
I ask every new family the same question in the first intake conversation. Walk me through your arm-care routine.
The list is almost always identical.
A pitch count app, checked after every game and every bullpen. Jaeger J-Bands, $38 to $40, used before every throwing session without fail. An ice wrap that gets offered after hard outings and used inconsistently because the kid fights it most nights. Biofreeze. Then Icy Hot when the Biofreeze stopped doing much of anything. Then whatever the parent in the next folding chair recommended at the last tournament.
Sometimes a magnesium spray they found online, that dried before he had finished rubbing it into his shoulder.
These families are not careless. The average family coming to me for private lessons has spent somewhere between two hundred and five hundred dollars on arm-care products in a single season. On top of the lessons themselves. On top of the tournaments. On top of everything else.
Then I ask the second question.
Is the lesson on that list?
The Signs I See In the Kids Who Come to Every Session
I have been watching this pattern from the mound side for over a decade.
The kid who throws clean mechanics for the first fifteen reps and then starts to shorten up somewhere around rep forty. Not a technique problem. A fatigue pattern I have seen hundreds of times, in hundreds of kids, that almost never gets talked about in parent-facing arm care conversations.
The kid who comes to Thursday's session moving differently than Monday's session. Tighter in the posterior shoulder. A little more armsy in the path. The follow-through gets slightly short, slightly guarded. I used to attribute it entirely to weekend game load.
I have a different explanation now.
The kid who says his arm feels a little tight when we start warming up, loosens up by rep twenty, and then quietly begins adjusting his mechanics around rep fifty to avoid something he is not saying out loud. He does not call it pain. He calls it "a little weird." I have to watch closely to catch it.
And the parent in the folding chair who tells me the pitch count looked fine all weekend. I believe them. The pitch count was fine. The lesson on Tuesday did not appear on the pitch count. The warmup before the lesson did not appear on the pitch count. The long toss on Thursday evening did not appear on the pitch count. His shoulder counted all of it. The chart counted none of it.
What I Now Walk Every Family Through Before the First Rep
This is the conversation I should have been having from the beginning. A sports-medicine PT I started referring athletes to a few years ago asked me something that changed how I run every intake.
"Do you tell parents that the lesson itself is part of the throwing load their arm-care routine needs to catch?"
I did not.
She explained the framework I now explain to every family before we throw a single rep.
Take your son's entire arm-care routine and sort every product, every step, into one of four categories.
Before throwing: J-Bands, dynamic warmups, arm circles, mobility work — everything that prepares the shoulder before it throws.
During throwing: Pitch counts, workload rules, inning limits, rest days between outings — everything that manages the arm while it is working.
Crisis response: Rest, ice, doctor visits, shutdowns, physical therapy, imaging — everything that responds when something has already gone wrong.
Ordinary after-throwing: The evening after the lesson. After the game. After the bullpen. After the long toss. After the backyard rebounder. Nothing acutely wrong. Nothing requiring medical attention. But the shoulder still did real deceleration work across every warmup throw, every rep in the session, every throw of the day.
Most families fill the first three buckets without any difficulty. The pitch count app goes in bucket two. The J-Bands go in bucket one. Ice and the doctor go in bucket three.
The fourth bucket is empty. Every single time I have run this audit with a baseball family.
And here is what makes this uniquely important coming from me as a coach: the lesson is throwing. Every rep we work through in a private session is a throw that ends with the shoulder actively braking the arm back down. That deceleration demand does not disappear because it happened in a lesson instead of a game. The pitch count only ever tracked one part of the throwing day. His shoulder counted everything.
"After every release," the PT explained to me, "the shoulder and upper arm have to slow the arm down. That is the brake phase. It happens on every throw. Pitching, long toss, warmups, lessons, the ball against the backyard wall. All of it has a stop. The scorebook counts pitches. His shoulder counts everything."
Then she explained why the bathroom counter full of menthol rubs was never reaching what the fourth bucket actually needs.
"Every contraction has two sides. Calcium helps the muscle fire. Magnesium helps support the process that lets it relax back down. A counter-irritant works on skin temperature receptors. Magnesium chloride works on the muscle relaxation side. Different system entirely."
That is why the Biofreeze seemed to work at first and then quietly stopped. The brain adjusted to the cold trick. The muscle underneath was never reached. The fourth bucket was never filled.
Grading the Routine, From Inside the Lesson
I go through every layer of the standard stack with every family now. Here is the honest coaching verdict on each one.
Pitch counts: important, and the right thing to track for game workload. The pitch count does not track the lesson. Does not track the warmup before the lesson. Does not track long toss, infield reps, the catching throws a dad makes in the driveway, or the backyard rebounder session after dinner. The chart sees part of the throwing. The shoulder sees all of it.
J-Bands: I use them myself before every session I run. They are exactly the right tool for bucket one — they activate and prepare the shoulder before it throws. They were never designed to help the shoulder recover after throwing. That is a different job, at a different time, for a different reason. A family who has J-Bands has the first bucket covered. The fourth bucket is still empty.
Ice: appropriate for acute inflammation. Fine when it actually gets used. But a twelve-year-old who has to sit still with a frozen wrap for twenty minutes at the end of a long lesson night and a long school day will resist that more nights than he follows it. The routine exists on paper. In practice, the fourth bucket receives nothing.
Biofreeze and Icy Hot: I have seen these in every baseball bag I have ever looked into. A real sensation. Zero effect on the muscle tissue underneath it. The brain adjusts to the cold signal over time, which is why families notice these products seem to work less and less as the season progresses. The mechanism was always surface-level. The muscle was never touched.
Magnesium spray: the right mineral, the wrong delivery. A spray that evaporates in sixty seconds is not a recovery step. The mineral needs contact time on the skin to function. Most sprays are gone before the application is even finished. The form was right. The delivery was not.
Every product in the standard stack lands in one of two timing windows. Before throwing. Or for when something already hurts enough to warrant attention.
Nothing in the stack was built for the ordinary after. The lesson ends. The kid drives home. The fourth bucket receives nothing.
What I Tell Parents to Look For
I do not recommend a brand first. I tell families what the fourth-bucket step needs to be.
Magnesium chloride as the active mineral, in a cream base rather than a spray, because contact time is what separates a real after-throwing routine from a gesture toward one. Nothing with a menthol additive, because the moment menthol enters the formula the product becomes a counter-irritant regardless of what else is on the label. No strong smell — because a product a tired kid refuses to use at the end of a long lesson night is not a routine. It is a product that sits in a cabinet.
A parent in my own roster had already started using it and sent me a message about it after the third week.
LeStrova Magnesium Relief Cream. Dead Sea magnesium chloride. 250mg per teaspoon. Cream, not spray. Built specifically for sore, tight, overworked throwing-arm muscles after baseball — not before it.
What I Want to Be Clear About Before I Recommend Anything
I want to be precise about this as a coach, not as someone selling a product.
LeStrova is not a treatment for Little League Shoulder, growth plate issues, rotator cuff strain, or any structural diagnosis. It would not have changed the outcome for any of the kids in my program who have had to shut down with those conditions. That is not what it does, and I would not tell a family otherwise. If a kid has sharp pain, worsening pain, popping, swelling, loss of motion, or pain that keeps coming back after rest, that is a medical evaluation, not a jar of cream. If a doctor says no throwing, that instruction stands regardless of what else is in the routine.
The three questions I hear from parents before they actually try it:
"Will it mask pain and let him throw through something he should stop for?" No. Counter-irritants mask pain by distracting the brain from the soreness signal, which is also why they stop working when the brain adjusts. Magnesium chloride does not interrupt a pain signal at all. It supports the muscle relaxation process after ordinary activity. If something is genuinely wrong, he will still feel it.
"Is it safe for a kid's skin every day?" Yes. Dead Sea magnesium chloride, lavender, calendula, shea butter, grape seed oil. No menthol, no harsh synthetic burn. No strong smell — which is specifically why kids will actually use it after a lesson night without being told twice.
"What makes a cream different from the magnesium spray we already tried?" Contact time. If the spray was gone before the application finished, the mineral did not have time to function. That is the only meaningful variable between a fourth-bucket step that works and one that becomes another item collecting dust on the counter.
What I Have Seen Change, Day by Day
The first family I walked through the bucket audit was a pitcher I had been working with for two full seasons. He came to Monday lessons moving clean — good arm path, fluid follow-through, consistent mechanics. He came to Thursday lessons moving differently. Tighter. A little shorter in the arm path. Not as fluid in the back side. I had been putting it down to weekend game load for months.
After the family added the after-lesson routine, he started showing up to Thursday sessions with the same arm fluidity as Monday. The mechanics had not changed. The fourth bucket had finally been filled.
Day 1. Post-lesson, post-shower, he applied it expecting the sting from the old rubs. Nothing. He told his mom it did not smell like the medicine stuff.
Day 5. He came home after a heavy bullpen session and asked where the cream was before she mentioned it.
Day 11. Fall tournament weekend. Three games over two days. He showed up to Monday's lesson moving better than I had seen him move after a tournament in two full seasons. Not because of anything I changed in his mechanics. Because the fourth bucket finally had something in it.
Week 2. His mom stopped tracking whether he had used it. He was tracking it himself.
Month 1. The jar was in his lesson bag, not in a cabinet at home someone had to remember to go find.
Month 2. Pitch counts during. Bands before. Rest on the days something feels real. A doctor if pain becomes sharp or persistent. LeStrova after every throwing session — lesson, game, long toss, bullpen, all of it. Not a recovery protocol for one bad week. A routine for every ordinary lesson day going forward.
A catcher in my roster whose mom had never connected arm care to catching because he barely pitched. A third baseman whose dad assumed the arm-care content did not apply to fielders. A utility kid playing three positions in a single travel ball weekend. The position changed every time. The empty fourth bucket did not.
Do Not Just Take My Word For It
I Cannot Make You Count What You Have Been Leaving Out
You have already been told to track the pitch count. You already have bands, ice, and a rub in the bag. You have invested thousands of dollars this season in your son's baseball development, in lessons and tournaments and gear and training.
You do not need a coach telling you that investment was wrong. It was not wrong. It was just never complete.
I am the lesson that does not appear on the pitch count chart. The warmup before the lesson does not appear on it either. The sixty reps we throw working on his arm path, the three extra at the end because we were close to something, the long toss after to finish loose — none of that is on any tracking system any parent in my program has ever shown me. His shoulder counted every rep. The chart counted zero of them.
The bucket audit takes thirty seconds. Most parents come out of it looking at an empty fourth slot they did not know was supposed to be there. The baseball mom found hers after a shutdown. You can find yours right now, before it gets to that.
The routine you built is real. The lessons you invested in are real. The three thousand dollars you put into this season is real.
It is just missing the one timing window no one told you to build. The window that opens every time the lesson ends and closes when he finally gets something for it.
Two categories is all most baseball families have ever had. Long-term arm care, or waiting for the next appointment. LeStrova is the third one.
You already built the warmup. Build the wind-down too.
With respect for the work you are putting into this season,
Coach Ryan Matthews
Private Pitching Instructor, Youth Throwing Athlete Specialist
P.S. — The 30-day guarantee means you risk nothing. Use it after lessons, games, long toss, bullpens, and tournament weekends. If it does not fill the fourth bucket that every throwing session has been landing in with nothing to receive it, send it back and get your money back. And if you are wondering whether a cream can make a meaningful difference after a season's worth of investment in your son's arm — the answer I kept coming back to is that the only thing I could not account for in every routine I had ever reviewed was what happened after the throwing stopped. LeStrova is what goes there.
